McKenzie’s Crap
McKenzie’s Crap
There is one point in McKenzie’s idiotic, immature, intellectually dishonest, defamatory review that I would like to clear up. She points out, quite correctly, that I wrongly attributed the article “Structural Realism” to Marc Lange instead of James Ladyman. How I made this mistake I don’t know, and I am surprised the referees didn’t catch it. I suppose that one such slip in thirty books and innumerable articles and book reviews isn’t a bad record, and I have no objection to McKenzie correcting it; but what follows this in her attempt at character assassination is very revealing about her motives and standards. She writes: “(One also can’t help but assume, of course, that he never actually bothered to read it.)”. I love that “of course”. This is pure gratuitous speculation, and I can assure her that I most certainly did read it, as I read the other works I cited. Is she implying that these other citations were also (“of course”) not read by me? She seems to think that if you get the author of an article wrong you must not have read it. This is neither necessary nor sufficient. She is clearly hell-bent on trying to discredit the intellectual reputation of the author in question (me). This is entirely typical of the whole review and disqualifies it as a piece of serious scholarship. I single it out because it is the one point on which she has truth on her side (I did misidentify the author of the article) and she manages to turn it into a false (and quite vile) accusation. If she had any integrity, she would publicly withdraw her scurrilous speculation; but of course, she won’t. Intellectual integrity was never the point.[1]
[1] I have written other replies to her shoddy nonsense on this blog, to which she is welcome to respond. So far, she has wisely chosen not to.

Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!