Davidson, Kripke, et al

Davidson, Kripke, et al

I recall a conversation I had with Donald Davidson circa 1976 in Heals vegetarian restaurant in London. At this time, I was 26 and he was 59. This was at the height of his influence. I asked him why he started publishing so late in life; he didn’t publish his first paper “Actions, Reasons and Causes” till 1963, making him 46. He replied without hesitation, saying it was intellectual insecurity (I forget his exact words). I was surprised: one would never accuse Davidson of intellectual insecurity (or any other kind). With his steely staccato voice and general air of self-confidence, insecurity was the last thing I would have imagined. On the other hand, he was saying some pretty radical things considering the state of philosophy at that time. It raises a puzzle: why the insecurity in a man so self-assured? It isn’t that he had anything but a stellar academic career up to that point—Harvard, etc. In later life there seemed to be no fear of publication, and his papers were widely applauded. I mean, 46 isn’t young—how did he get tenure? We then moved on to the topic of Saul Kripke, as one did in those days. He remarked, “He can do more in half an hour than the rest of us can do in a year” (these were more or less his exact words). This raises a puzzling question about Kripke: why did he publish so little in later life? Apparently, the ideas for which he is famous were formulated when he was still a young man, though published quite a bit later. He was very productive when young but rather unproductive when middle-aged; we can call this “A Puzzle About Kripke”. Kripke was remarkably precocious but not too post-cocious. Was he not able to find that elusive half hour, or did it go deeper? I mean, the man gave his “Naming and Necessity” lectures without notes, and he was a notably charismatic and confident lecturer. It’s as if he turned into a young Davidson in later life. Deep into the quiche, Don and I proceeded to Tyler Burge, both of us commending his productivity, Don adding “and such a steady stream too” (I hear his precise voice now). Not for Burge, this halting insecurity, early or late, but a steady stream. We finished lunch and parted on cordial terms. I had a good impression of him, though left feeling rather puzzled.

Share
0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.