Entries by Colin McGinn

A Road Song

I’m reading Paul McCartney’s The Lyrics and figured I needed to write a road song (compare Route 66).   A Road Song I got my foot on the gas I got my hands on the wheel I’m heading down to Miami To seal the deal I’m a real estate broker If you really want to […]

Share

Evolution of Pain

This paper follows on from “The Cruel Gene” and “Pain and Unintelligent Design” on this blog.   Evolution of Pain Pain has evolved over many millions of years. Presumably it had primitive forms that were subjected to natural selection. It was honed and whittled, modified and amplified. There are now several species of pain, each […]

Share

Rejecting the Analytic-Synthetic Distinction

Rejecting the Analytic-Synthetic Distinction  If we cannot make sense of the idea of a synthetic truth, it looks as if we have to reject the analytic-synthetic distinction (the reverse of post-Quine orthodoxy).[1] There is nothing coherent for the concept of analytic truth to contrast with (a genuine distinction requires meaningful things to be distinct). Yet […]

Share

Are There Synthetic Truths?

Are There Synthetic Truths? There is a tradition, stemming from Quine (but not pre-dating him), claiming that the concept of analytic truth is undefined, or ill-defined, so that the analytic-synthetic distinction cannot be made sense of; accordingly, there are only synthetic truths. I think this is the opposite of the truth. Nothing is true but […]

Share

Preposterous Presidents

The recent debacle involving the presidents of three top American universities is symptomatic of a deeper and more widespread malaise. The moral obtuseness and intellectual ineptitude of these three women is just part of a general degradation in American universities and intellectual life. I won’t go into the causes of this, but what appalls me […]

Share

Consciousness, Paralysis, and Functionalism

Consciousness, Paralysis, and Functionalism Paralysis has been regularly used to defeat behaviorism and its descendant functionalism. How can the mind consist of behavior if paralysis is consistent with having a mind? The objection is clear and strong: paralysis shows that behavior is not required for consciousness to exist. To have a conscious state is not […]

Share

Macro and Micro Necessity

Macro and Micro Necessity A curious fact of necessity studies: although necessity is liberally spoken of, its extent is rarely tabulated. We find reference to necessities involving people and items of furniture (and the occasional cat) but little in the way of mapping the full distribution of necessities in the world, or their interconnections. We […]

Share

A New Metaphysics of Necessity

A New Metaphysics of Necessity There is a tacit recognition in the history of philosophy that in order to account for necessity we need to introduce a split in what we regard as overall reality. Thus, we have the idea that necessity resides in meaning, conceived as separate from the ordinary reality of things and […]

Share