Nina Strohminger’s Review

Nina Strohminger’s Review

The trouble with Strohminger’s infamous review of my The Meaning of Disgust is very simple: she didn’t know the philosophical literature in which my book was rooted. She knew only the psychological literature. She was ignorant of the work of Kolnai, Becker, Menninghaus, Miller, and others. The general position she so uncomprehendingly attacked was common to all of us not my own creation, as was the methodological approach. Nor did she understand philosophy in general, being a psychologist. I understand both, having degrees in both. In addition, as a female graduate student remarked to me, she is a “sassy bitch who thinks she’s funny”. I would say she belongs in that large class of people who mistake their own ignorance for superior wisdom. She is a philosophical philistine, in short. When I replied to her ill-considered attack in Emotion Review I pointed this out as gently as I could, to which she responded that my theory was not empirically testable; but this is true of large tracts of philosophy (and is not really true of the theory in question—the “death-in-life” theory). Philosophy is not an empirical science like psychology. I even sent her a politely worded email asking if she was acquainted with the literature in question but got no reply—I wonder why. Her problem was not with me in particular but with the philosophical literature surrounding the topic of disgust, and indeed with philosophy itself. You would never guess this from the tone of the review. My own opinion is that her review was complete rubbish—a pile of shit, to use her own description of my book. Elsewhere the book was reviewed quite soberly and favorably. I wonder if she stands by her review today. If I were her, I would put it down to the excesses of youth.[1]

[1] Do you think I enjoy having to make these points? I do not. There are better uses of my time.

Share
4 replies
  1. Janus
    Janus says:

    She seems to be a serious scientist now. At the time she wrote her review, she had just earned her Ph.D., which may explain why she was so aggressive. She writes well, though.

    Reply
    • admin
      admin says:

      It was a mistake for editors to give her my book for review, because it is a philosophy book and psychologists are not philosophers. But that doesn’t absolve her from responsibility; what she wrote was nasty rubbish, utter shit.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.