Ted Honderich Review
Ted Honderich Review
I have written many book reviews in my life, around eighty, I think. Some are quite critical. My review of Honderich’s book was the most critical of the lot. It caused quite a stir. Honderich and others ventured some psychological speculations about why my review was so critical; these were completely false. I just thought the book was intellectually terrible. He made an effort to improve his exposition in subsequent years, with mixed success. Many people seemed to think I should be given the same treatment whether I deserved it intellectually or not. It was ugly stuff. Responsible book reviewing is a thankless task. I am glad I haven’t been invited to write many reviews in the last ten years. But the point I want to make is that no one in the years since the review was published has come forward to defend Honderich’s book or his position, or to respond to my criticisms of same. No one has offered to reply to the criticisms I made of the book or the theory of consciousness Honderich proposed. Nor has anyone argued that my criticisms were too harsh or extreme; it has all been misguided psychology. It’s as if everyone agrees that I was perfectly right in the substance of my criticisms but that I shouldn’t have said it; but what else is a responsible reviewer to do? Should I have pretended that the book was better than it was or sugarcoated my objections, substantive and stylistic. If you want to object to my critical response, read the book then come back to me—but no one has done that. I knew just what I was doing and thought hard about doing it, but it was the only intellectually responsible thing to do. You may disagree, but you need to put in the work first. I would be quite happy to reply if you do that. Unlike some others, I defend my negative reviews if challenged and have done so many times. I don’t just run away after lambasting someone. There is an ethics of book reviewing; it carries obligations with it.

Apart from the judgment you rendered on the work being completely warranted by its poor contents, the blistering tone and cutting style of your review was also a fitting response to the false bravado and superciliousness with which Honderich delivered his shoddy fustian. It’s not as though your harshness was lacking in justification, intellectual or moral. A completely different case from penning a review that is ham-fisted in criticism, devoid of any sort of charity, and unjustifiably rude and mean-spirited in style (both true of the Strohminger and McKenzie reviews). What Honderich wrongly accused you of—venting your vitriol and enacting a vendetta against him—seems true of these reviews.
An astute assessment. My harsh tone was appropiate to the style of Honderich’s book, especially his disrespect of others. And you are quite right about the gratuitous bile of Strohminger and McKenzie–people I have never met and had not heard of. What prompted this poison? Didn’t they realize they were asking for trouble?