UM Philosophy Department

UM Philosophy Department

Prompted by Risto Hilpinen’s recent death, I took a look at the current membership of the philosophy department at UM. They have lost all but one senior member (Michael Slote, age 85) in the last few years to retirement, death, or resignation—Harvey Seigel, Susan Haack, Ed Erwin, Risto Hilpinenen, and Colin McGinn. They have not replaced these people with anyone comparable, and I doubt they will. The department is greatly reduced and in relatively poor shape. This was quite predictable. I wonder what it is like to be there now.

Share

New Schedule

New Schedule

Now that I am no longer churning out philosophy, there is a question how I am going to use my time (what remains of it). I have hit on a new schedule: I am going to play tennis twice a day, like a professional player. Instead of staying home and writing all morning, I will head over to the Biltmore tennis wall around 11am and practice for an hour or so. This will involve me in getting out of the house before noon (!), thus breaking the habit of a lifetime. I am looking forward to it—seeing the world in the early hours of the day. I started this habit yesterday and found it quite agreeable. Then in the afternoon I will play again, generally with a partner for an hour or so. Yesterday I felt a marked improvement in my game in the afternoon session, rested but in the groove. I am expecting improvements in fitness too; I sit around at home too much. I am also intending to put more time into my music, but tennis is the priority. I also experienced a minor miracle in my right ear two days ago: that ear was near to deaf after a couple of operations on or close to it, but for some reason some hearing came back into it from nowhere. I am now hearing reasonably well with it. In any case, I am mainly hoping that my left arm will keep improving with regular practice, twice a day. I can now hit a decent forehand drive with it. Who says old dogs can’t learn new tricks?

Share

Davidson, Kripke, et al

Davidson, Kripke, et al

I recall a conversation I had with Donald Davidson circa 1976 in Heals vegetarian restaurant in London. At this time, I was 26 and he was 59. This was at the height of his influence. I asked him why he started publishing so late in life; he didn’t publish his first paper “Actions, Reasons and Causes” till 1963, making him 46. He replied without hesitation, saying it was intellectual insecurity (I forget his exact words). I was surprised: one would never accuse Davidson of intellectual insecurity (or any other kind). With his steely staccato voice and general air of self-confidence, insecurity was the last thing I would have imagined. On the other hand, he was saying some pretty radical things considering the state of philosophy at that time. It raises a puzzle: why the insecurity in a man so self-assured? It isn’t that he had anything but a stellar academic career up to that point—Harvard, etc. In later life there seemed to be no fear of publication, and his papers were widely applauded. I mean, 46 isn’t young—how did he get tenure? We then moved on to the topic of Saul Kripke, as one did in those days. He remarked, “He can do more in half an hour than the rest of us can do in a year” (these were more or less his exact words). This raises a puzzling question about Kripke: why did he publish so little in later life? Apparently, the ideas for which he is famous were formulated when he was still a young man, though published quite a bit later. He was very productive when young but rather unproductive when middle-aged; we can call this “A Puzzle About Kripke”. Kripke was remarkably precocious but not too post-cocious. Was he not able to find that elusive half hour, or did it go deeper? I mean, the man gave his “Naming and Necessity” lectures without notes, and he was a notably charismatic and confident lecturer. It’s as if he turned into a young Davidson in later life. Deep into the quiche, Don and I proceeded to Tyler Burge, both of us commending his productivity, Don adding “and such a steady stream too” (I hear his precise voice now). Not for Burge, this halting insecurity, early or late, but a steady stream. We finished lunch and parted on cordial terms. I had a good impression of him, though left feeling rather puzzled.

Share

Bond-Mobil

Back of my car–you have to laugh. We are all James Bond now; the fascination never dims.

IMG_7084.jpeg
Sent from my iPhone

Share

Types of Psychologist

Types of Psychologist

When I was young and studying psychology, I fancied the idea of becoming an educational psychologist. I was fresh out of school and aware that the psychology of learning is as important as the subject matter learned, perhaps more so. I envisaged helping people with learning problems. I am still interested in this subject. Later my mind turned to sports psychology, no doubt because of my sporting interests, and I can imagine being a professional sports psychologist. It isn’t all about how you move and hit the ball but includes what goes on in your head. Now that I’m old, I have discovered the subject of medical psychology, which I think is grievously underserved. I mean patient psychology: anxiety, fear, hope, illusion, panic, depression. I don’t know how much time is given over to this in medical school, but I think it is vital. Can you imagine what is going through the minds of people undergoing extended radiation treatment for cancer (I have experienced it firsthand)? If I were a professional psychologist, I would get into that type of psychology—the psychology of illness. You see, I am still a psychologist—educational, sports, and medical. Is there a psychology of philosophy? Yes.

Share

Ballroom Vernacular

Ballroom Vernacular

I was watching Dancing with the Stars last night and marveling at the skill demonstrated (in high heels too). Someone uttered the immortal line “I left it all on the dance floor”, which struck me as hilarious. It occurred to me that this would be an excellent catchphrase for other types of effort-achievement: for example, you give a philosophy paper and comment “I left it all on the dance floor”, and same for a business presentation or a tennis game or a kitchen clean-up. You get the idea. Then someone remarked “That was the paso doble of the season”: this could be used to describe any type of outstanding performance—academic, athletic, domestic. The more absurd the comparison the better. I wonder if it will catch on.

Share

Ted Honderich Review

Ted Honderich Review

I have written many book reviews in my life, around eighty, I think. Some are quite critical. My review of Honderich’s book was the most critical of the lot. It caused quite a stir. Honderich and others ventured some psychological speculations about why my review was so critical; these were completely false. I just thought the book was intellectually terrible. He made an effort to improve his exposition in subsequent years, with mixed success. Many people seemed to think I should be given the same treatment whether I deserved it intellectually or not. It was ugly stuff. Responsible book reviewing is a thankless task. I am glad I haven’t been invited to write many reviews in the last ten years. But the point I want to make is that no one in the years since the review was published has come forward to defend Honderich’s book or his position, or to respond to my criticisms of same. No one has offered to reply to the criticisms I made of the book or the theory of consciousness Honderich proposed. Nor has anyone argued that my criticisms were too harsh or extreme; it has all been misguided psychology. It’s as if everyone agrees that I was perfectly right in the substance of my criticisms but that I shouldn’t have said it; but what else is a responsible reviewer to do? Should I have pretended that the book was better than it was or sugarcoated my objections, substantive and stylistic. If you want to object to my critical response, read the book then come back to me—but no one has done that. I knew just what I was doing and thought hard about doing it, but it was the only intellectually responsible thing to do. You may disagree, but you need to put in the work first. I would be quite happy to reply if you do that. Unlike some others, I defend my negative reviews if challenged and have done so many times. I don’t just run away after lambasting someone. There is an ethics of book reviewing; it carries obligations with it.

Share

Nina Strohminger’s Review

Nina Strohminger’s Review

The trouble with Strohminger’s infamous review of my The Meaning of Disgust is very simple: she didn’t know the philosophical literature in which my book was rooted. She knew only the psychological literature. She was ignorant of the work of Kolnai, Becker, Menninghaus, Miller, and others. The general position she so uncomprehendingly attacked was common to all of us not my own creation, as was the methodological approach. Nor did she understand philosophy in general, being a psychologist. I understand both, having degrees in both. In addition, as a female graduate student remarked to me, she is a “sassy bitch who thinks she’s funny”. I would say she belongs in that large class of people who mistake their own ignorance for superior wisdom. She is a philosophical philistine, in short. When I replied to her ill-considered attack in Emotion Review I pointed this out as gently as I could, to which she responded that my theory was not empirically testable; but this is true of large tracts of philosophy (and is not really true of the theory in question—the “death-in-life” theory). Philosophy is not an empirical science like psychology. I even sent her a politely worded email asking if she was acquainted with the literature in question but got no reply—I wonder why. Her problem was not with me in particular but with the philosophical literature surrounding the topic of disgust, and indeed with philosophy itself. You would never guess this from the tone of the review. My own opinion is that her review was complete rubbish—a pile of shit, to use her own description of my book. Elsewhere the book was reviewed quite soberly and favorably. I wonder if she stands by her review today. If I were her, I would put it down to the excesses of youth.[1]

[1] Do you think I enjoy having to make these points? I do not. There are better uses of my time.

Share